Anthony's Pizza & Pasta Reviews
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 97 reviews. Customer feedback on Anthony's Pizza & Pasta is mixed: Anthony's Pizza & Pasta reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, generous portion sizes, friendly staff, quick service, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, casual diners, local residents. However, Anthony's Pizza & Pasta is often criticized for its inconsistent food quality, higher prices, limited parking, long wait times during peak hours.
97 reviews
5 Stars
21
4 Stars
4
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
5
1 Star
0
How would you rate Anthony's Pizza & Pasta?
All Anthony's Pizza & Pasta Reviews (97)
RickyEdwards_07
May 04, 2026
"Everyone there is just so friendly"
Stopped in today and the staff were super nice. it feels like everyone who works there is always friendly and easy to talk to.
0
Reply
BUTTERFIELD
May 02, 2026
"This tasted so fresh, honestly. You could…"
This tasted so fresh, honestly. You could tell right away it wasn’t sitting around for ages (which always makes a difference). I’d definitely get it again.
0
Reply
veramiller4798
April 29, 2026
"Hot, Fresh, and Easy to Recommend"
The pizza showed up hot and everything was packed really well with no mess. The boxes held up nicely too, which is always a plus. Overall, I was happy with it and would definitely recommend giving it a try.
0
Reply
joyce.Funk
April 28, 2026
"Sauce was probably the best part"
Ordered from Anthony's Pizza & Pasta the other night, and the sauce was what stood out to me the most. It had that good tomato flavor, maybe a little sweet and a little garlicky, but not too heavy or overpowering.
I’m kind of picky about pizza sauce, and this one was pretty much right where I like it. It made the whole pie taste better, so I’d definitely order from them again sometime.
I’m kind of picky about pizza sauce, and this one was pretty much right where I like it. It made the whole pie taste better, so I’d definitely order from them again sometime.
0
Reply
Michael.bourland
April 22, 2026
"Comfortable Spot for a Relaxed Pizza Night"
I stopped in for pizza and didn’t expect to notice the seating as much as I did, but it was surprisingly comfy. The booths had plenty of room and didn’t feel cramped like they do at some pizza places, so I could actually sit back and enjoy my meal without feeling rushed. We ended up hanging out a little after we finished eating, and it still felt relaxed. The tables were spaced out well too, so we weren’t awkwardly bumping elbows with anyone nearby. It’s a simple thing, but the overall vibe felt comfortable and easygoing, which made the whole meal better.
0
Reply
BradleyKlein_99
April 12, 2026
"Perfectly Crispy Crust"
The crust came out perfectly crispy every time, which made the whole thing so much better. Weirdly, I remember the little crackly sound it made when I cut into it more than anything else...
0
Reply
julie-Timko
April 10, 2026
"Pretty good portions overall"
I ordered from Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta last weekend i was a little surprised by how much food we got. The pasta tray was bigger than I expected, and we even had enough left over for lunch the next day. The pizza slices were a decent size too, thankfully not those tiny slices you get from some places. I’m giving it 4 stars because the side salad was kind of small compared to everything else, which was a little disappointing. But overall, I can’t really complain, the portions were solid and I was happy with the order.
0
Reply
justin_Bivins83
April 05, 2026
"Food showed up late, and my..."
Food showed up late, and my order was wrong again. Frustrating.
0
Reply
JonathanElliott_98
April 05, 2026
"Easy Visit with the Kids"
Went here with my kids and it was easy, which is always a win. The staff were nice and there were plenty of food options, so nobody had a meltdown over what to eat... It did get a bit noisy, but I guess that’s kind of expected with a place like this.
0
Reply
John_beamon99
April 04, 2026
"Easy checkout and no surprises"
Ordered dinner from Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta and paid through the site. The payment page was super easy to follow, and there weren’t any weird extra steps or confusing parts. My card went through fast, and I got the confirmation right away. I also appreciated that the total was clearly shown before I paid, so there was no guessing. Overall, really smooth checkout. I’d definitely use it again next time we order pizza.
0
Reply
judith-Vanhamlin
April 04, 2026
"Anthony’s is in such a handy spot…"
Anthony’s is in such a handy spot for me... there’s easy parking nearby, and I can grab a pizza on my way home without having to go out of my way...
0
Reply
Darleen_forbis77
April 02, 2026
"Always a Solid Pizza Spot"
I’ve been here a few times now the pizza is just consistently good. Nothing overcomplicated, no big dramatic review needed, it’s just one of those places where you know what you’re getting and it hits the spot every time.
0
Reply
rebecca_Jost79
March 30, 2026
"Quick and easy help"
I had a small issue with my order, but they got back to me really fast. The person I spoke to on the phone was super nice and sorted it out without making it a whole thing. i really appreciated how easy they made it.
0
Reply
hello_theodore550
March 26, 2026
"Quick fix after a small mix-up"
There was a little mix-up at first, but uh, they got it sorted out really quickly. I appreciated how easy they made it to fix.
0
Reply
debra-Barber
March 23, 2026
"That cheese was seriously good"
I ordered from Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta, the cheese on the pizza was what stood out the most. It was super melty, tasted fresh, and had that perfect cheese pull without feeling greasy. I know it sounds like a small thing, but it really made the whole pizza better. If you’re picky about pizza cheese like I am, I think you’d be happy with this one. I’d definitely order again just for that
0
Reply
joseph_Cox80
March 15, 2026
"Fresh, Tasty Pizza I’d Definitely Order Again"
I grabbed a pizza from Anthony’s it hit the spot. The toppings tasted really fresh, like the peppers still had that nice crunch, and the mushrooms didn’t have that canned flavor at all. It was just a simple, really good pizza, and I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
Clyde-hajdas
March 11, 2026
"Fair prices and good portions"
The prices felt fair for what we got. The pizza and pasta portions were solid, and there werent any weird extra charges or surprises. I’d definitley order from here again...
0
Reply
Evelyn-bowers
March 04, 2026
"Plenty of options for everyone"
It was easy finding something for everyone, even my vegetarian sister, which is not always... yeah. The menu was clear and simple to choose from, and nobody felt stuck with just one option. I’d definitely order again.
0
Reply
ann1983
February 21, 2026
"Pizza came quick and was still hot…"
Pizza came quick and was still hot when it got here, so no complaints from me.
0
Reply
michaelmulkey8873
February 18, 2026
"Gets the job done, but feels a bit messy"
The website is fine if you just want to check the menu or find a nearby location, but it’s definitely a little clunky. A few pages took longer to load than I expected, and the ordering process wasn’t super obvious at first. I also found it kind of unclear who actually owns or manages the different locations, which made it harder to know who to contact if something went wrong. It works overall, but it could be a lot smoother and more straightforward
0
Reply
Have a question about Anthony's Pizza & Pasta?
Log in to ask your Anthony's Pizza & Pasta question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
